Mansfield State Reformatory and Societal Priorities

Following a successful Alumni Weekend, for Father’s Day I chose to visit the Ohio State Reformatory in Mansfield, Ohio with my wife Sandy. Many of you may know this institution as the setting of The Shawshank Redemption or other films, but beyond the silver screen it served as one of Ohio’s primary prisons from the end of the 19th century up to 1990 when it was closed under federal court order. Given new life from notoriety gained from Shawshank, the site currently serves as a museum and has an active preservation society.1 It has also been the subject of several paranormal investigations, and purportedly houses some “angry” ghosts.2 From the outside, it’s a beautiful building with fascinating architecture resembling a castle, although this ornate exterior belies a gloomy interior of cellblocks and iron bars.

As my family will attest, I have a longstanding fascination with prisons and jails. From 1990-1992, I worked as a correctional officer at the Lincoln Correctional Center, a medium and maximum-security facility housing around 850 inmates in Lincoln, Nebraska. In 1992, I left this position for graduate school, leading to my current role in higher education. While I cannot say for certain that my career path is unique, I’ve yet to meet a fellow college president who previously worked as a prison guard, so it is safe to say my path is uncommon.

Beyond my personal experience, though, my interest in how we deal with crime and incarceration centers on what it reveals about our values and priorities as a society. At one point the United States led the world as a reformer in jails and prisons, and the development of incarceration was a move away from punishments like mutilation, beatings, and public humiliation. More recently, though, the US leads in a more dubious category – incarceration per capita – among the world’s democracies with 614 individuals incarcerated for every 100,000 in the population, as the graph below reproduced from the Prison Policy Initiative shows.3 Despite having less than 5% of the world’s population, the US has nearly 25% of the world’s incarcerated individuals.4 This has not always been the case: as the second graphic demonstrates, the prison population in the US stayed relatively steady from the mid-1920’s until around 1970 when it started on a long, sharp increase. This was in part due to increased crime rates starting in the 1960s but defies such a simple explanation as these had varied considerably during earlier periods. Even when crime rates dropped, prison populations kept rising. There was a clear shift to more “tough on crime” policies followed by both major political parties.5 Ultimately, these policies had substantial financial implications. In the US, we spend $80 billion annually on corrections, but this is just the direct costs of running facilities, paying officers and the like. Estimates of the overall impact, including indirect costs, are that for every dollar spent on incarceration incurs an additional $10 in social costs, borne primarily by families of those incarcerated, but also by communities.6 Those indirect costs are things like lost wages, lost tax income and increased reliance on social services. According to the US Department of Justice, at the end of 2022 there were 5,407,300 people under some sort of correctional control in the US, or 1 in 48 (2%) of US residents.7

Incarceration rates among founding NATO countries
State policy drives mass incarceration

Ohio Costs of Incarceration vs Hiram Cost of Attendance

According to the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction December 2024 Fact Sheet, the annual cost of incarcerating an individual in Ohio was $38,598. With a total population of 45,490 in Ohio’s 27 state prisons for adults and 3 juvenile facilities, that works out to around $1.8 billion dollars spent annually to control inmates. Despite this investment, around one in three inmates released from Ohio’s prisons will return within 3 years after release. Ohio is not alone, as the United States as a whole – at the local, state, and federal levels – invests huge sums of taxpayer funds in probation, parole, jails, prisons, and the wider criminal justice system necessary to keep so many people incarcerated.

Meanwhile, most of us have probably heard about (or directly felt) the increasing costs of college. While there are several factors responsible for this, one primary driver is a reduction in state support for public schools, but this also can affect private schools like Hiram. In last year’s incoming class, 50% of our students were eligible for Pell grants and nearly 24% received Ohio College Opportunity Grants (OCOG) . Both programs support students of lower socioeconomic standing and are critical to providing access. Neither Pell nor OCOG has kept with inflation, and this year Pell was under serious threat of being reduced.

The sticker price of a Hiram education for 2024-25 was $39,4508, but because all our students receive some form of financial support, no student paid that much. In fact, in 2023-24, the average net price for Hiram was $32,054 even when tuition discounts, room, board, and books are included. Compared to the cost of incarcerating an individual in Ohio, it costs less to attend Hiram. While state and federal support partially offsets the costs for many Hiram students, taxpayers bear the full cost of every incarcerated individual.

Investing in the Future vs Warehousing

You may still be wondering what these issues have to do with one another. My argument is that investing in higher education (or education more generally) is a wiser investment. Those who complete a bachelor’s degree are more likely to find employment, have higher lifetime earnings, pay taxes, engage in their communities, and give back to society. According to the National College Attainment Network, in Ohio each additional post-secondary graduate increases state GDP by over $117,000, increases home values, produces jobs, expands the tax base by over $4,000 and pays back the state portion of post-secondary expenses within 5.5 working years.9 Investing in education is an investment in society. While prisons and jails are necessary elements of living in a complex society, incarcerating such large numbers of people as we do in the US creates a drag on public finances and offers little in return. Ideally, we would like to divert people from committing crimes and ending up in jails and prisons.

The biggest takeaway from my experience working in corrections is that those who occupy our prisons and jails come overwhelmingly from groups of people who have had fewer life chances than others. Go visit an exercise yard at one of these institutions and you will be hard-pressed to find many with degrees or who come from middle-class backgrounds. It’s not that all people incarcerated are poorly educated or come from lower socio-economic status, but the vast majority do. Given the high rates of recidivism and the “churn” of people on pre-trial detention in our jails, investing more in education to avoid clogging our criminal justice system with people seems an obvious choice, yet recently there were proposals to reduce Pell Grants – grants for college education made to those most in need – although those are apparently on hold for now. Despite the grandiose exteriors of some of our prisons and jails there is very little correction or reform going on behind the concertina wires. In contrast, Hiram continues to build on its 175-year legacy of generating opportunity for those who may lack socio-economic wealth but have talent and a desire to change their life’s trajectory.

At Hiram, one of the outcomes I am most proud of is our performance in social mobility.10 We are proudly one of Loren Pope’s original “Colleges that Change Lives”.11 This is not a recent development. Future US President James A. Garfield came to Hiram in 1851 as the poor child of a single mother. Although tuition was much cheaper then, Garfield paid his way through school by working as a janitor, ringing the morning bell, and doing odd jobs. I like to think he created his own work study program!

At our most recent commencement, when I asked graduates for a show of hands for students who worked during their time at Hiram, hands went up everywhere. Our commencement speaker, Dr. Marlena Hudson, told an inspirational story of overcoming challenges to excel at Hiram and go on to career at NASA. These are just two of many success stories and overcoming challenges that are part of Hiram’s DNA since its inception. When an institution has created as many success stories as Hiram has, it serves not only the individuals who benefit from a Hiram degree, but the community, state, and nation as well. Times are tight for schools like Hiram – rural, liberal arts institutions with relatively small endowments – and those of us who work at these institutions must do a better job of explaining the vital role we play, and we need the help of our alumni and friends in spreading the word and supporting the mission. In an era where we need critical thinking, communication skills, and the ability to work with others more than ever, we need to rally and support small liberal arts schools and invest in tomorrow.

As I mentioned in the outset, my goal is to provide better communication and perhaps some insight into the opportunities and challenges facing Hiram College and higher education. This is the first of a semi-regular series of posts, so if you’ve found this interesting, stay tuned. Fiat Lux!

By Rob Bohrer


[1] See https://www.mrps.org/ for more information on the Ohio State Reformatory.

[2]https://usghostadventures.com/americas-most-haunted-trending/the-ohio-state-reformatory-mansifeld-ohio-dark-legacy/)

[3]https://www.prisonpolicy.org/global/2024.html

[4]https://www.brennancenter.org/issues/end-mass-incarceration

[5]Pfaff, John. 2017. Locked In: The True Causes of Mass Incarceration – and How to Achieve Real Reform. Basic Books.

[6]McLaughlin, Michael, Carrie Pettus-Davis, Derek Brown, Chris Veeh, and Tanya Renn. “The Economic Burden of Incarceration in the United States.” Institute for Justice Research and Development at Florida State University Working Paper #IJRD-072016.

[7]https://www.ojp.gov/archives/pressreleases/2024/about-2-percent-adult-us-residents-under-correctional-supervision-2022

[8]Hiram College Tuition

[9]https://www.ncan.org/

[10]https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/hiram-college-3049

[11] Pope, Loren (1996). Colleges That Change Lives:40 Schools You Should Know About Even If You’re Not A Straight – A Student. Penguin Books